cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Replies are disabled for this topic. Start a new one or visit our Help Center.

Best beacon interval for 5Ghz wifi?

WRD2093AU
Community Member

I recognise Google Nest does not support users choosing which channels are offered by Nest across both 2.4 and 5 Ghz and that it offers both bands with exact same SSID.  With my old router setup (pre-nest) I could that one of my laptops with  Realtek RTL8822CE wifi card would often choose to connect to 2.4Ghz SSID rather than connect to 5Ghz SSID if the 5Ghz setting was any channel above 48.   When I reduced the 5Ghz channel on the router the laptop was much more likely to connect to  5Ghz.  But with Nest I have lost that capability to pre-select the channel (and the same SSID used for both bands).

So since switching to Nest, where I can't select channel for 5Ghz, it seems to use channel 149 for 5Ghz and sure enough I find this one laptop often choosing 2.4Ghz even though I am sitting next to one of the Nest wifi points.    Sometimes I see it connected to 5Ghz at 149 ... but later I might notice it back on 2.4Ghz ... so it rather unpredictable.  Also the Windows driver for this wifi card does not allow me to prevent it from connecting to 2.4Ghz, although I have selected it to "prefer 5Ghz".  So basically I am at the mercy of the wifi card and Nest to randomly decide whether to use 2.4Ghz or 5Ghz.

After reading about beacon interval, have changed the beacon interval for the adaptor in Windows from 100 to 300 ... as that supposedly should favour 5Ghz where reception is strong.  Wonder if anyone has tried using higher beacon intervals to force a laptop to use 5Ghz over 2.4Ghz?  Or I have misunderstood the effects of changing Beacon Interval on the device?

6 REPLIES 6

MichaelP
Diamond Product Expert
Diamond Product Expert

Hello @WRD2093AU 

Just a couple thoughts here. First, while Nest WiFi does provide clients with some extra information they can use to make better decisions about which band to connect to, which access point to connect to, and when to switch, clients are still in charge of those decisions. Worse yet, many clients ignore the extra information Nest WiFi provides (since the 802.11k and 802.11v specifications are optional). So, if your laptop is connecting to 2.4GHz, it is because it has decided that is the best option. That could be because it isn't doing a great job of making that decision, but it could also be because there is a source of 5GHz interference nearby that is making 5GHz a poor choice. Things like wireless gaming headsets and wireless subwoofers / surround sound speakers can all cause these issues, since they often use the same part of the 5GHz spectrum, but not using a WiFi-compatible channel structure. I've even seen cases where someone had a wireless internet service provider that was interfering in that part of the band. Oddly, it's also possible to be too close to the access point. If you're within three feet, it could be a problem. So, I would investigate this angle to see if you can figure out what may be happening.

As for beacon interval, that is a network-side configuration, not something client devices can change. In some very high density environments (e.g., enterprise / office), it can make sense to use a longer beacon interval just because there are so many access points all beaconing at the same time. But, in a home environment, even with a few secondary mesh points, the standard beacon interval shouldn't be a problem. This also shouldn't have any impact on which band a device selects, since beacons are sent independently on both bands. I'm curious why a client device would even have a configuration setting for this, unless it is part of some internet connection sharing feature where it can act like an access point, or maybe WiFi Direct?

WRD2093AU
Community Member

Thanks for your insights about the beacon and about possible interference.  I will continue to experiment as to when it drops to lower band ...  and also pursuing question in the laptop manufacturers forum (in case there are any driver or firmware updates that might help).  Ideally the network card should not be having problems with staying on channel  149 on 5Ghz (which Nest seems to be using) ... and 2 other windows laptops and a desktop in the home don't seem to have the issue with staying on the 5Ghz band.

Jeff
Community Specialist
Community Specialist

Hi, WRD2093AU.

It looks like you and MichaelP were able to get some answers here, but I wanted to check in real fast to see if there was anything else you needed here. If you still need some help, just let me know.

Thanks.

Jeff
Community Specialist
Community Specialist

Hey, WRD2093AU.

I just wanted to check in one last time real quick. We'll be locking the thread in the next 24 hours, but I want to keep it open if you still needed help. If so, just let me know.

Thanks.

WRD2093AU
Community Member

That's fine ... thanks for the help.

Jeff
Community Specialist
Community Specialist

No problem. If you have any questions or need anything else going forward, please feel free to open a up a new thread.

Thanks.