02-05-2024 04:11 PM
Hi all,
I have two questions -
1. I have nest router with google wifi 1st gen points. All are wired. All of the points show great connection except one which shows good connection. I would expect them all to have great connection as they are wired. Why isn't so? I would just state is a switch after the nest router and all of the points are connected directly to it.
2. I have read (on google guideline and also @David_K here in the forums) that I should not connect more than 5 wifi points (i.e. in my case the google router and 4 more points). Does this concern only 5 points meshed wirelessly? or also wired points it not good to have more than 5?
Thanks in advance!
02-06-2024 07:06 AM
Hello @lobsterboy
I'll try to answer as best I can.
1. When a wired point shows as "good" instead of "great" on a mesh test, it's often due to the Ethernet cable connected to that point only managing to negotiate and hold 100Mbps (using one pair of wires) instead of the full 1Gbps (all four pairs of wires). Occasionally, it can "flap" between 100Mbps and 1Gbps, leading to an effective throughput higher than 100Mbps, but less than 1Gbps. This is rare, but not impossible. I would check on the details of that point to ensure it shows as being connected "wired" rather than mesh, and then ensure the cable connecting it is working properly. One thing that can happen is using a Cat6 cable (which is stiffer than Cat5e) ends up bending enough to get to the jack on the Google WiFi unit that it results in poor connection of some pins. When this happens, the cable is fine – and testing it will show it's fine, including by connecting something else to it – but, it won't work reliably in the Google WiFi. If this is happening, and replacing the cable is not an option, you can pick up an inexpensive 5-port Ethernet switch, and connect it to the long cable run, then use a more flexible Cat5e cable from that switch to the Google WiFi unit.
2. The limit of 5 total units applies to mesh-connected systems, not wired. However, I would caution against installing a large number of wired points. It can work, but they still use a common 5GHz WiFi channel, so performance improvements when there are a lot of access points isn't necessarily better. If they are very close to each other, client devices may be less likely to hand off between them.
02-06-2024 02:29 PM
@MichaelP ,thank you very much for your helpful answer!
02-06-2024 02:40 PM
@MichaelP btw if we are here 🙂 how do you suggest I set my network? is one way better than the other?
A. nest router -> switch -> google wifi -> switch -> other wired devices
B. nest router -> switch -> switch -> google wifi and other wired devices
* each '->' means wired connection
Thanks again!
02-06-2024 03:11 PM
I prefer option B personally. A will work, but the ports are switched in software, so I think it's more efficient and more reliable to build a pure switched network and hang everything off of it.