01-06-2022 02:51 AM
Nest Wifi intermintantly picks a device at random and wont issue the correct ip address. The device is connected to the wifi but with no internet, soon as you go into the settings on the said device the issue is obvious. DHCP hasn't assign an IP address.... and it has 172.16.1.___ instead of the usualy 192.168.86.____
There are periods where there are no issues though, sometimes a few weeks can pass trouble free. Having said that no previously connected device seems to be immune from the random issue. Its has happend to iPads, Samsung tablets, samsung phones, 2 different TCL google TVs etc ( having said that, The Xbox, PCs and Sony TV haven't had the issue yet. The only thing that resolves this issue for me imediately is to assign a static IP address with the correct prefix 192.168.86.___ and the correct gateway 192.168.86.1 on the DEVICE, and suprise suprise everything instantly connects to the internet.
Having to do this is very frustrating all the time.
I have troubleshooted and done everything i possibly can to resolve this.
Factory resets, restarts, restarts and connecting devices in sequence you name it, I even investigated an date a time issue that it could have possibly been......
Network Devices I have in my network bellow
TP-Link Archer VR600v, Netgear Switch GS724Tv4, Nest Wifi x 3 ( 1xrouter 2xaps ) and are connected in the following order bellow
TP-link ( in bridge mode) ---> Nest Wifi Router ----> Netgear Switch (dhcp disabled recieves ip from nest router) ----> wired devices (PC, Printer, Laptops, NVR etc) All other devices in my house are wireless and theres about 20 or more, they range from TVs, phones, tablets, toys, xbox's etc.
Like i said, this issue is random, and intermittant, which ever device it decides it wont issue an ip address to, is a device that would have been previously succesfully connnected to the network with flewless internet functionallity.
So why is the Nest Router doing this from time to time????
PS: Assigning every single device in my network with a static IP address is not a solution, and VERY ANNOYING.
Anyone out there got some insight here?
Answered! Go to the Recommended Answer.
04-11-2022 09:14 PM
Ok, so for my particular sitation I have discovered the problem. As it turns out it was indeed a rogue dhcp server, blows my mind really. I'll try to give everyone the manner in which I targetted the issue and hopefully this will assist some of you.
Step 1. https://www.tachytelic.net/2019/05/detect-rogue-dhcp-server/ Go to this website and read it
Step 2. Follow its instructions to the letter, by that I mean install the Rogue DHCP server detection application, use it when the problem is occuring, discover the IP address, use that ip address to discover the MAC address and then use that MAC address to discover the Manufacturer of that device on https://macvendors.com/
In my particular instance what was occuring was my SWANN Securitry NVR, which is meant to have a closed off private DHCP for my IP Security Cameras was occasionally issuing IP address to some of my devices. The same was happening Visa Versa, a couple of my IP cameras where being issued IP address by my Google Nest WIfi.
Basically once I was able to discover the device (in my case one of the IP cameras) and then use its ip to attain its MAC address, then using that to discover the manufacturer (in my case the offender was SWANN SECURITY). That basically pointed me in only one direction. My Network Video Recorder.
I'm still baffled as to why this was happening but in any case, after playing around with the network setting on the NVR, I basically had to turn off the internal DHCP, have the IP address for the cameras assigned manually, aswell as reserved an IP address for the NVR its self on my google nest and then also assigned that IP manually on the NVR.
I have had problem free operation since - and its been over 2 months. Problem solved in my case.
Not everyone has the same equipment in thier house but I'm sure, that if you follow this proceedure you should be able to point your self in the direction of the offending device.
Hope this helps, Cheers.
06-25-2022 04:28 PM
Did you figure this out? I am having the same problem, changed DNS, the rogue scan is pointing to google wifi router.
06-27-2022 12:37 PM
Repost: I've now been just using bridge mode with the Nest WIFI router with forced IP assignment
Primary Server 8.8.8.8
Secondary Server 8.8.4.4
IPV6 Server 2001:4860:4860::48
I have had zero issues with IP's since then.
07-11-2022 09:28 PM
The only thing that seems to help was I shut off ipv6 and upnp. Seems to have cleared it up for a while now
08-22-2022 11:34 AM
I am now experiencing the same issue. I have a Mac so I can’t run the rogue detection software (am also very unfamiliar with all of the terminology anyway.)
using the guest network works for me but I’d obviously like to resolve the issue still
earlier this week I was using a raspberry pi to run pihole and pivpn but when this issue started, I shut down the pi and reverted the settings I had touched in the google home app (dhcp reservation, port forwarding, dns setting). The only thing that won’t delete is dhcp address pool. Not sure if this even has anything to do with the issue
08-22-2022 12:11 PM
Repost: I've now been just using bridge mode with the Nest WIFI router with forced IP assignment
Primary Server 8.8.8.8
Secondary Server 8.8.4.4
IPV6 Server 2001:4860:4860::48
I have had zero issues with IP's since then.
Everything beyond bridge mode can be set in the WIFI settings in the home app.
08-22-2022 12:50 PM
Feedback I got from support
———
You can clear some cache on the cloud server by disabling-enabling the Nest Wifi cloud services.
Home app > Wifi icon > Settings > Privacy settings > toggle off and on the Nest Wifi cloud services.
also pause and unpause family wifi group
———
04-23-2023 12:14 PM
Same issue for me but I dont have any rogue dns servers I run pi-hole for DNS and set Google wifi to DHCP range of one IP address. That IP is assigned to HD Homerun and uses a .99 address. My DHCP range is 100-150 on my primary dns server and 151-200 on secondary. Occasionally that device it will fall off that .99 address into the DHCP range. Rebooting that device usually fixes the issue. But not sure why it's happening honestly and continues to be an ongoing issue.
06-03-2023 02:08 PM
Hello everyone,
Thanks for posting and I'm sorry for the delayed response. Let’s see what’s going on.
A few questions: was this working fine before? If yes, when did the issue start? What's your network topology? Aside from the reboot, what troubleshooting steps have you taken?
Looking forward to your response.
Best,
Lovely
06-06-2023 04:22 PM
Hi there UncleBabyBilly,
I want to ensure you are good to go. Please reply to this thread with the information asked above if you still need assistance so I can give you a helping hand.
Cheers,
Lovely
06-07-2023 04:51 PM
Hey UncleBabyBilly,
It's me again. I'll be locking this thread in the next 24 hours. If you have new issues, updates or discussion topics, feel free to start a new thread here in the Community.
Many thanks,
Lovely